Audio

What I've Learned Building Subwoofers

Lessons from my subwoofer builds: a three-way shootout of 20 Hz subs, how they ranked for fun, sound quality and value, and what building the CSS SDX12 taught me.

November 18, 2026 6 min read Nick Wilbur
Three DIY subwoofers in a shootout: a tall orange ported 15, a blue ported 15 with three slot ports, and a small black cube 12

Three subwoofers, all tuned to 20 Hz, all with almost identical frequency responses. So which one hits the hardest, which one sounds the best, and which one would I actually put in my theater? That shootout taught me more about DIY subwoofer design than a frequency graph ever did.

Some links on this page are affiliate links (Parts Express). If you buy through them, Toid may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Bass at the levels in this shootout is hard on your ears, and some movie scenes are known to blow subwoofers up.

Browse my DIY speaker plans

Watch the subwoofer shootout · 13 min

Three DIY subwoofers, one room

The setup

My co-host Robbie brought his Dayton HO 15. He has two, but we only tested one. We also had the Dayton Audio MX15, the new Max Excursion 15 that a lot of you were excited about. And the smallest of the three was the CSS SDX12, a 12 inch with dual passive radiators, which is also, interestingly enough, the most expensive.

All three were tuned for movies, down to 20 Hz, to get the bass response most subwoofers don't give. That matters for the HO. It would typically be tuned to about 30 Hz, but we extended its bass response down to 20 Hz, lower than most people would run one. The two 15s also ended up in exactly the same size box, 5.3 cubic feet, built differently but the same volume. We played them through clips like the light cycle scene in Tron, the Battle of Normandy in Saving Private Ryan and the opening of Underwater, paired with our Klipsch THX-style inspired speakers, which get very loud and very clean.

On-screen list of the three shootout subwoofers: MX15-22, RSS390HO-4 and CSS SDX12 with passive radiators

Power turned out to be part of the design

Each sub got a different amount of power, and that changed how we judged them. The HO was limited to closer to 400 watts. The MX15 was on one side of the Crown with full power, and we only limited it a little because the amplifier was clipping, not because of the subwoofer. The SDX12 had the highest power handling of the three, so we bridged the amplifier to run it.

As we talked about in the video, the way the HO was built, it doesn't need a lot of power. With the right amp, around 200 watts would get by. We ran two of them on just one side of that kind of amp, and it was phenomenal.

The scoreboard

  • Smallest footprint: SDX12, easily. The other two are the same exact cubic feet.
  • Most fun: MX15, then the HO, then the SDX12. Robbie and I felt the same on this one.
  • Best sound quality: we both picked the SDX12. It's significantly more expensive, but that's what the extra money gets. Second place was hard. We felt the HO came in a little cleaner than the MX15 because it doesn't have as much output.
  • Best value: MX15, then the HO, then the SDX12. The SDX12 is last only because it's the most expensive and takes the most power.
  • Overall: MX15, followed by the HO, followed by the SDX12.

The SDX12 didn't really sound like a subwoofer. It blends in, and you feel the bass more than you hear it. The MX15 is in your face. The one concern we raised with the MX15 is that without pretty efficient, clean speakers, it could definitely overpower them. With the Crown's fourth-order cutoff right at 120 Hz, none of the voices were getting through to it. It was just pure bass.

Toid and his co-host sitting in black theater recliners talking about the subwoofer results

The principle: no replacement for displacement

When money is no object and there's all the amplifier power needed, we both said the MX, at least for theater. For pure sound quality for music, the pick was the SDX12. The SDX12 is awesome, but you just can't beat the output of the 15s. There is no replacement for displacement. The way we summed up the three: you buy the SDX12 because you want the cleanest subwoofer you can buy, the MX because you want lots and lots of bass, and the HO for the blend of it, a good price point and not needing a ton of power if you tune it right.

What building the SDX12 taught me

I built that SDX12 from CSS's flat pack. It weighs about 70 pounds, and it has so much bracing that it makes a completely inert box. It's the best flat pack I can remember ever coming across. There are no instructions, just a few diagrams, and the cabinet has a little bit of CNC tolerance built in. That's why I didn't tighten the clamps all the way until all the pieces fit around the cube, and why gluing the whole outside of the cabinet at once worked best. I added glue at every joint, because I never want to get back inside that box.

The driver itself is about 50 pounds, and CSS gave it a double front baffle because it needs one. I used T-nuts with machine screws instead of wood screws. My usual quarter-inch T-nuts with pro audio drivers wouldn't fit, so it needed something more like a 10-24. For the passive radiators, basic wood screws were fine, and CSS included the weights. I ran it off the Crown XTi 2002, which has built-in DSP I can save and label for each subwoofer.

Clamps holding together a plywood subwoofer box in the workshop during the SDX12 build

What did I think? It's the best sounding 12 inch subwoofer I can remember having my hands on. From my normal listening position I couldn't hear any motor noise or strain, all the way up to the point where I needed to turn it down. It's not the loudest, and some subs I've built probably go a little deeper. But it's an 18.5 inch cube getting down to 20 Hz with HiFi quality bass.

What I expected going in

Going into the shootout, the expectation was that all three would give almost identical frequency responses. The question was never the graph. It was which one hits the hardest, sounds the best and is the most fun, and that's exactly where they split apart.

Mistakes and limits

On the SDX12, I bought feet off Amazon purely because they looked amazing. What I didn't realize is that they use an adhesive backing. On a box this heavy, they fell off the first time I moved it. I'd typically use feet that screw in, and I don't recommend those.

After the shootout we hooked the MX15 to one side of the Crown and both of Robbie's HO 15s to the other and watched movies. The pressure in the room was unbearable for me, and I actually had to leave. We had it turned up entirely too loud and were giving them all full power when we didn't need to. It's a really cool feeling to pressurize a room like that, but it could have been done with quite a few decibels less.

Frequency response graph with two nearly overlapping curves from the subwoofer shootout

Two more design lessons from my channel

In one Short, I walked through matching a driver to a box using the specs. A 6.5 inch I looked at needed a bigger box, 0.57 cubic feet, for a vented F3 of 49 Hz. A 12 inch in a small two cubic foot box probably isn't going to be the size someone wants for 39 Hz. For a small box with a really low F3, something like the Tang Band W5 is the kind of driver I'd look at.

In a clip from one of my livestreams, the point was made that effective 21 inch subwoofers weren't around 20 years ago. Home theater subs tuned to 20 Hz aren't unheard of now, so port noises like chuffing have moved lower in frequency. More important, people have gotten better at designing subwoofers, with tools like WinISD hitting the mainstream maybe 15 years ago.

More subwoofer builds

For a sub on a much smaller budget, see my ISO-100 isobaric subwoofer under $100. For bass built into a bookshelf speaker instead of a separate box, see the Dinas powered bookshelf speakers. The full CSS SDX12 build video covers the finish work too.

Keep building: ISO-100: a DIY subwoofer under $100 · Dinas powered bookshelf speakers with a built-in sub · all my DIY projects

Parts Used and Mentioned

Here's what was in the shootout and the SDX12 build, with an honest label on each. Prices change, check the current price.

Some links below are affiliate links. Toid may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Item Used / mentioned Link
Dayton Audio MX15-22 15" Max-X subwoofer Used: my sub in the shootout. Parts Express
Dayton Audio RSS390HO-4 15" Reference HO subwoofer Used: Robbie’s sub in the shootout. Parts Express
CSS SDX12 XBL2 12" subwoofer Used: the SDX12 I built and tested. The flat pack and passive radiators came from CSS. Parts Express
Crown XTi 2002 power amplifier Used: the amp for the shootout and the SDX12. Parts Express showed it out of stock or on backorder when checked. Parts Express
Tang Band W5 subwoofer Mentioned: a small-box example in my Short. No link available
Adhesive-backed feet Used, and not recommended: they fell off the SDX12. No link available